A Teenager's Revenge Over Grades: The Murder of Nohema Graber

In today’s True Crime Tuesday episode of Love and Murder, I, Ky, take you to the quiet town of Fairfield, Iowa, where the community’s sense of security was shattered by a murder that rocked the very foundations of trust between teachers and students.

The victim, Nohema Graber, a beloved Spanish teacher at Fairfield High School, was found brutally murdered in a local park. Her assailants, two 16 year old teenagers – Jeremy Goodale and Willard Miller.

As we dissect the investigation, their sentencing hearing – a spectacle of attempted justifications and psychological evaluations – reveals the impact of their crime on a family, a school, and an entire community.

Listen to my reaction to this case:

Listen to "True Crime Tuesday - A Teenager's Revenge Over Grades: The Murder of Nohema Graber" on Spreaker.

In this week’s poll, I ask: Do you think the sentences handed down to the young men were sufficient? Cast your vote and let your voice be heard.

The victim, Nohema Graber, a beloved Spanish teacher at Fairfield High School, was found brutally murdered in a local park. Her assailants, two 16 year old teenagers - Jeremy Goodale and Willard Miller.

Willard Miller and Jeremy Goodale

Florida Mom of 4 Found Murdered in Ex-Husband’s Storage Unit – Shakeira Rucker

True Crime Rants Florida Man Fridays – Inmate Pulls 3 Syringes Out of His Rectum, Claims They’re Not His – Wesley Dasher Scott

PA Woman Allegedly Murdered Boyfriend’s 18-Month-Old Daughter by Poisoning Her

« Older Entries

Next Entries »

Join the LaM Patreon for More Rants

Join Now

Primary Topic: Case Background
– Noima Graber’s career as a flight attendant and one of Mexico’s first female passenger jet pilots
– Close relationship with ex-husband’s family and well-loved in the town’s Latino community
– Arrest and charges of two 16-year-old males, Willard Miller and Jeremy Goodall, for first-degree murder and conspiracy to commit a forcible felony
– Pleas of not guilty and request for reduced bond
– Arguments by defense and prosecution regarding the detention of juveniles
Primary Topic: Trial Evidence
– Posts on social media as integral evidence
– Jeremy’s confession in a recorded phone conversation and during interrogation
– Testimonies from family members and a psychologist to explain Jeremy’s behavior and home environment
– Criticism for making excuses for Jeremy’s actions and not addressing the severity of the crime
– Willard’s motive for the murder based on frustration over a grade and college resume improvement
Primary Topic: Sentencing and Court Case Outcome
– Willard’s guilty verdict and sentenced to life in prison
– Jeremy’s plea deal and sentence between 25 years to life with parole possibility
– Consequences faced by both individuals for the murder of Noima Graber
– Judge’s remarks on Willard’s actions and lack of justification for the murder
Primary Topic: Community Reaction
– Fear and concern expressed by teachers and parents for safety in schools
– Fairfield Community School District’s commitment to supporting the community and remembering the victim
Primary Topic: Victim’s Family and Forgiveness
– Noima’s son expresses forgiveness towards the defendants
– Daughter emphasizes the need for love and forgiveness in the aftermath of the murder

Willard Miller and Jeremy Goodale charged with first-degree murder

Willard Miller and Jeremy Goodale are charged with first-degree murder from Iowa Courts Online

Want to get more true crime news? Sign up for Love and Murder’s FREE True Crime newsletter. Get current crime news, little known past cases, and podcast episode updates.